To the content
2 . 2022

Formation of the organoleptic profile of sugar cookies with a modified fat component


Currently, as part of solving the problems of improving the quality and safety of food, research is underway on the introduction of oleogels into foodstuffs to replace solid fats, which contain saturated and trans-isomeric fatty acids. However, such a replacement leads to a change in the organoleptic characteristics of food.

The aim of the work was to identify the characteristics that affect the difference in the perception of cookie descriptors baked using hard fat and oleogels.

Material and methods. Three batches of sugar cookies samples with different fat components were produced for the study: butter cookies; cookies based on oleogel structured with beeswax; and cookies based on oleogel structured with combinations of beeswax fractions. Organoleptic evaluation was carried out by two methods: the triangle method according to ISO 4120:2004 and the free-choice profiling method according to ISO 13299-2015. In this case, the profile was derived statistically, by means of a generalized Procrustes analysis.

Results and discussion. The analyze of cookies samples using the triangle method showed there was no noticeable difference between the control cookies samples and cookies with oleogel structured with beeswax, but there were significant differences with cookies baked with the use of oleogel structured with a combination of fractions. Generalized Procrustes analysis was used to interpret the results of the descriptor profile analysis. It was shown that differences in perception between samples were due to the severity of the following descriptors: Creamy flavour, Fat flavour, Floral flavour, Waxy flavour, Shape. A close correlation has been established between individual descriptors characterizing the samples under study.

Conclusion. The data obtained as a result of the conducted studies allow not only to judge the acceptability of the use of oleogels in cookies from an organoleptic point of view, but also to identify individual characteristics that affect the perception of cookie samples. In the future, this information can be used to optimize the formulation of finished cookies containing oleogels in order to change the organoleptic profile in a targeted manner.

Keywords:oleogels; cookies; sensory profile; descriptor-profile analysis; beeswax; beeswax fractions

Funding. The study was carried out with the support of the Russian Science Foundation (Project No. 19-16-00113).

Conflict of interest. Authors declare no clear or potential conflicts of interest.

For citation: Frolova Yu.V., Sobolev R.V., Sarkisyan V.A., Kochetkova A.A. Formation of the organoleptic profile of sugar cookies with a modified fat component. Voprosy pitaniia [Problems of Nutrition]. 2022; 91 (2): 93–8. DOI: (in Russian)


1. Yang J., Lee J. Application of sensory descriptive analysis and consumer studies to investigate traditional and authentic foods: a review. Foods. 2019; 8 (2): 54. DOI:

2. Asioli D., Varela P., Hersleth M., Almli V.L., Olsen N.V., Naes T. A discussion of recent methodologies for combining sensory and extrinsic product properties in consumer studies. Food Qual Prefer. 2017; 56: 266–73. DOI:

3. Frolova Yu.V., Kochetkova A.A., Sobolev R.V., et al. Oleogels as prospective nutritional ingredients of lipid nature. Voprosy pitaniia [Problems of Nutrition]. 2021; 90 (4): 64–73. DOI: (in Russian)

4. Bascuas S., Espert M., Llorca E., Quiles A., Salvador A., Hernando I. Structural and sensory studies on chocolate spreads with hydrocolloid-based oleogels as a fat alternative. LWT. 2021; 135: 110228. DOI:

5. Silva-Avellaneda E., Bauer-Estrada K., Prieto-Correa R.E., Quintanilla-Carvajal M.X. The effect of composition, microfluidization and process parameters on formation of oleogels for ice cream applications. Sci Rep. 2021; 11 (1): 1–10. DOI:

6. López-Pedrouso M., Lorenzo J.M., Gullón B., Campagnol P.C.B., Franco D. Novel strategy for developing healthy meat products replacing saturated fat with oleogels. Curr Opin Food Sci. 2021; 40: 40–5. DOI:

7. Li S., Wu G., Li X., Jin Q., Wang X., Zhang H. Roles of gelator type and gelation technology on texture and sensory properties of cookies prepared with oleogels. Food Chem. 2021; 356: 129667. DOI:

8. Meng Z., Guo Y., Wang Y., Liu Y. Oleogels from sodium stearoyl lactylate-based lamellar crystals: structural characterization and bread application. Food Chem. 2019; 292: 134–42. DOI:

9. Sarkisyan V., Sobolev R., Frolova Y., Malinkin A., Makarenko M., Kochetkova A. Beeswax fractions used as potential oil gelling agents. J Am Oil Chem Soc (JAOCS). 2021; 98 (3): 281–96. DOI:

10. Frolova Yu.V., Sobolev R.V., Kochetkova A.A. Research of cookies with modified fat component. Pishchevaya promyshlennost’ [Food Processing Industry]. 2021; (4): 8–11. DOI: (in Russian)

11. Oreskovich D.C., Klein B.P., Sutherland J.W. Procrustes analysis and its applications to free-choice and other sensory profiling. In: Sensory Science Theory and Applications in Foods. New York, 1991: 353–93.

12. Frolova Y.V., Sobolev R.V., Kochetkova A.A. Comparative analysis of the properties of cookies containing oleogel based on beeswax and its fractions. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science (EES). 2021; 941 (1): 012033. DOI:

13. Doan C.D., To C.M., De Vrieze M., Lynen F., Danthine S., Brown A., et al. Chemical profiling of the major components in natural waxes to elucidate their role in liquid oil structuring. Food Chem. 2017; 214: 717–25. DOI:

SCImago Journal & Country Rank
Scopus CiteScore
Viktor A. Tutelyan
Full Member of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Doctor of Medical Sciences, Professor, Scientific Director of the Federal Research Centre of Nutrition, Biotechnology and Food Safety (Moscow, Russia)
Индустрия и медицина 2022
Medicine today

XXIII Всероссийский научно-образовательный форум "Мать и Дитя − 2022" 28 - 30 сентября 2022 года в очном формате состоится XXIII Всероссийский научно-образовательный форум "Мать и Дитя − 2022" - самое значимое мероприятие для акушеров-гинекологов и смежных...

Уважаемые коллеги, приглашаем принять участие в конференции "Бронхоэктазы: муковисцидоз и не только..." в Воронеже, которая состоится с 23 по 24 июня Организаторы: · Общероссийская общественная организация "Российское общество медицинских генетиков"; · НМИЦ...

7-8 июня 2022 года "Фёдоровские чтения" объединили молодых талантливых офтальмологов Летний сезон Общество офтальмологов России открыло Всероссийской научно-практической конференцией с международным участием "Фёдоровские чтения"! Это одно из немногих российских...

Journals of «GEOTAR-Media»